王峰 AI × 经营 约一次诊断

总目 / 文章 / WF-0062

文章 · 存档

忽悠了那么多年,AI至今也没替代会计

十多年前,各种文章和报告预测会计行业将是最早被人工智能(AI)取代的职业之一。

这些预言使得会计行业的从业者每天如履薄冰,如坐针毡,担心随时会被AI淘汰。

然而现实却出乎意料,会计行业不仅没有被AI取代,反而在职业市场上依然名将难求。

相比之下,网约车司机、外卖小哥和程序员等职业却感受到了更大的冲击。那么,为什么会计行业至今仍未被AI替代呢?

会计行业的独特性

数据准确度要求极高。会计工作对于数据的准确性和可靠性要求极高。会计人员不仅需要处理大量的数据,还需要确保每一笔交易的准确记录。这不仅仅是简单的计算和录入,更需要深厚的专业知识和对相关法规的了解。虽然AI在处理大量数据方面具有明显优势,但在确保数据准确性和处理复杂交易方面,仍然无法离开人工的审查和确认。

会计人员的内卷与管理。会计行业内卷严重,竞相考取各种证书,这个行业不允许躺平,也就更加容易选拔出优秀人才。不过,另一个角度思考,会计人员成天被教育要规避风险,所以大多数会计人员对风险心存芥蒂,也就相对容易被管理。会计从业者通常具备较高的专业素养和职业道德,工作态度认真细致。相比之下,其他一些职业可能更难管理,存在较高的人员流动性和职业风险。正因为会计人员的稳定性和专业性,使得会计行业在面对AI的冲击时显得更加从容。

记账会计成本低廉。这一条也确实很悲催,基层会计工作者的收入普遍都不太高。会计工作的基础部分——记账和基础账务处理,其实人工成本很低。一个市场现象就可以展示,以最基础的代理记账为例,一个公司一个月的费用才200元人民币。即使是再智能的AI系统,也难以以如此低廉的成本来替代这些基础的会计工作。对于许多中小企业来说,雇佣一个代理记账的会计人员远比购置和维护一套AI系统要划算得多。

其他职业的动荡

网约车司机与外卖小哥。网约车司机和外卖小哥等职业在当下受到了智能技术的巨大冲击。无人驾驶技术和智能配送系统的发展,使得这些职业面临着更大的替代风险。虽然实际应用中仍面临许多挑战和限制,说完全取代尚为时过早。但随着这些技术不断进步,这些职业受到冲击将会是致命的。

程序员的危机。程序员这个曾被视为高薪和高技术含量的职业,也随着大模型的推广已经完全处于威胁状态中。自动化编程工具和智能代码生成器的出现,使得一些基础性的编程工作变得不再那么需要人力。虽然复杂的系统设计、创新和问题解决仍然需要高水平的程序员来完成,但还是那句话,基层职业的冲击也是致命的。

会计行业的稳固性

稳定的就业人数。根据统计,全中国的会计从业人员大约有500万人。这是经过多年持续积累和发展的结果。相比之下,全中国的网约车司机大约700万,出租车司机大约300万,快递员大约8000万,外卖小哥大约1300万,程序员也不低于700万人。这些职业虽然有些辛苦,但整体收入往往高于会计人。然而,这些职业的人员流动性较高,稳定性较差。

高度专业化和综合能力。会计工作不仅仅是记账和报表,还涉及税务筹划、财务分析、内部控制、风险管理等诸多方面。会计人员需要具备广泛的知识和综合能力,才能胜任这些复杂的工作。AI在这些方面还难以完全替代人工的判断和决策。

责任与保险。外卖小哥和快递员出差错的后果相对较小,网约车司机可以依靠自动驾驶技术和保险来降低风险,而会计的错误往往会导致严重的后果,如税务问题、财务舞弊等。会计工作的高风险性使得AI难以完全替代,因为AI系统的失误没有相应的保险机制来承担这些责任。因此,AI在会计领域的应用面临更大的挑战。

未来展望

会计与AI的协同发展。虽然AI无法完全替代会计工作,但会计行业也在不断拥抱技术进步。智能会计软件、自动化报表生成、数据分析工具等技术的发展,为会计人员提供了强大的支持。未来,会计人员将更多地依靠智能工具,提高工作效率和准确性,实现人机协同。

会计职业的转型与提升。会计职业未来将朝着更加专业化、综合化的方向发展。会计人员需要不断学习和提升自己的技能,适应技术发展的潮流。通过掌握新的技术工具和方法,会计人员可以在更高层次上发挥自己的价值,为企业提供更加全面的财务管理和决策支持。

忽悠了那么多年,AI至今也没替代会计。

会计行业之所以能够稳如泰山,不仅仅是因为其工作内容的特殊性,更因为会计人员的专业素养和职业道德。

在未来,随着技术的不断发展,会计行业将迎来新的挑战和机遇。

会计人员需要不断学习和提升自己,与AI协同发展,为企业和社会创造更大的价值。

让子弹再飞一会儿,或许会计行业将迎来更加辉煌的明天。

AI Still Hasn't Replaced Accountants After All These Years

For more than ten years, people have been saying that accounting would be one of the first jobs to be taken over by AI.

Accountants were really worried they'd lose their jobs to AI any day now. But guess what?

That didn't happen.

In fact, accountants are still in high demand.

Meanwhile, jobs like rideshare drivers, delivery folks, and programmers are feeling the heat from AI more.

So, why hasn't AI taken over accounting yet?

Why Accounting is Special

Needs Super Accurate Data: Accountants have to make sure every number is right. They deal with a lot of data and have to make sure every single transaction is recorded perfectly. This isn't just about typing in numbers. It needs a lot of knowledge about the rules and laws. AI is great with lots of data, but it still needs humans to check and make sure everything is correct.

Accountants are Careful and Easy to Manage: The accounting field is very competitive, with people constantly trying to get more certifications. This makes sure the best people rise to the top. Also, accountants are trained to avoid risks, so they are usually cautious. This makes them easier to manage compared to other jobs where people might quit more often.

Basic Accounting is Cheap: Sadly, many entry-level accountants don't get paid a lot. Basic accounting tasks, like bookkeeping, have very low labor costs. For example, a company might only pay about 200 RMB a month for basic bookkeeping services. It's hard for even the smartest AI to be cheaper than that. For many small businesses, hiring a bookkeeper is cheaper than buying and maintaining an AI system.

Other Jobs Facing Turbulence

Rideshare Drivers and Delivery Folks: These jobs are being hit hard by smart tech. Self-driving cars and smart delivery systems mean these workers might lose their jobs soon. Although there are still challenges with these technologies, they're advancing quickly, and that spells trouble for these jobs.

Programmers in Crisis: Programmers, who used to have high-paying, high-tech jobs, are now feeling threatened by AI too. New tools can write basic code automatically, so fewer human programmers are needed for simple tasks. Complex programming and creative problem-solving still need skilled people, but the basic jobs are at risk.

Why Accounting Stays Strong

Stable Job Numbers: There are about 5 million accountants in China. This number has grown steadily over time. In comparison, there are about 7 million rideshare drivers, 3 million taxi drivers, 80 million couriers, 13 million delivery people, and at least 7 million programmers in China. These jobs might pay more but have high turnover and less stability.

Highly Specialized Skills: Accounting isn't just about bookkeeping. It involves tax planning, financial analysis, internal control, and risk management. Accountants need broad knowledge and skills to handle these tasks. AI can't fully replace human judgment and decision-making in these areas.

High Stakes and Responsibility: Mistakes by delivery folks or drivers aren't as serious as accounting errors, which can lead to big problems like tax issues and fraud. The high stakes in accounting make it hard for AI to take over because mistakes need a human to take responsibility.

Looking Ahead

Working with AI: AI can't fully replace accountants, but it can help them a lot. Smart accounting software, automated reports, and data analysis tools support accountants in their work. In the future, accountants will use these tools to be more efficient and accurate.

Evolving Accounting Jobs: Accounting will keep getting more specialized and complex. Accountants need to keep learning and adapting to new technologies. By mastering these tools, accountants can add more value to their companies and make better financial decisions.

For years, people said AI would replace accountants, but it hasn't happened yet.

The unique nature of accounting work and the professionalism of accountants have kept the industry strong.

As technology advances, accounting will face new challenges and opportunities.

Accountants need to keep learning and working with AI to create even more value for businesses and society.

So, let's see what the future holds—accounting might just get even better!