王峰 AI × 经营 约一次诊断

总目 / 文章 / WF-0197

文章 · 存档

不懂审计不懂会计的马斯克

DOGE审计法Musk's DOGE Audit

美国人居然也如何胆大妄为的胡作非为?

0亿美元款项流向无有效身份证明的个人!

每年约500亿美元(每周10亿美元)可能涉及欺诈支付!

更哭笑不得的是,网上一美国大爷视频里说,

全美松鼠普查机构每年230万美元数松鼠;

三明治标准委员会每年500万美元就只是为了定义什么才是合法的三明治;

不平坦人行道意识局每年180万花费就为了提醒脚下不平;

鸭子协会每年花费400万美元来证明鸭子的嘎嘎声不会回声。

我的天哪,我脑子里立刻浮现出小岳岳那个贱气啷当的样子。

当年安然公司财务造假案曾经让多少投资者倾家荡产,市场信心遭受重创。

如今美国政府财务体系里藏着的这些问题,规模之大、危害之深,简直有过之而无不及,这背后到底是监管的严重失职,还是存在着更为复杂的利益纠葛?

马斯克的 DOGE 团队就像是从天而降的奇兵,一举终止 199 份浪费性合同,省下约 2.5 亿美元,累计为政府节省 367 亿美元。

难以想象6个毛头小子完全不懂会计完全不懂审计,居然把几十年审计未曾发现的问题给完全暴露出来。

他们没有被传统审计那些刻板的 “专业流程” 束缚住手脚,在传统审计还在按部就班地核对账目、检查凭证时,他们已经另辟蹊径。

传统审计就像一个被设定好程序的老旧机器,看似严谨有序,实则僵化保守。在面对那些精心设计的财务陷阱和巧妙伪装的欺诈手段时往往只能望洋兴叹。

我们身边的审计就是这样,审计人员按照常规流程检查发票、合同,却怎么也想不到企业和供应商早已勾结在一起,通过虚开发票来套取巨额资金,传统审计就这样被蒙在鼓里。

马斯克团队呢?

他们靠着创新思维和先进技术打破了常规,在审计过程中他们运用大数据分析技术,将海量的财务数据进行整合、筛选,就像在茫茫大海里精准定位目标,迅速找出异常的资金流向;

借助人工智能算法,对财务数据的趋势进行预测,一旦数据出现异常波动,立刻展开深入调查。

正是这些大胆的尝试和创新,让那些被传统审计忽视了几十年的问题,彻底暴露在阳光下。

那为啥传统审计在如此巨大的财务漏洞面前毫无察觉呢?

或许我们客观的去看待这个问题,并不是以前的审计蠢,而是以前的审计有“依据”,也就是说这1000亿的支出在账面上都是有依据的。

先不管这个依据是否靠谱,但这个依据是获得被审计单位官方认可的,你审计就不能说这是违规的,因为这个“规”是被审计单位定的。

所以这个锅,不应当审计背。

但审计委托模式的不合理和审计手段的落后,的确就是事实。

当审计委托方是被审计单位时,审计人员就像是在别人的地盘上办事,处处受制于人。

被审计单位完全可以通过各种手段,炮制出看似合规的财务依据,就算这些依据是伪造的或者被歪曲的,审计人员要是敢质疑,就可能面临失去业务、遭到报复的风险。

在某些地方政府的审计项目里,审计人员明明发现了当地企业和政府部门之间存在利益输送的问题,可因为害怕得罪人,只能把真相深埋心底,假装什么都没看见。

再看看传统审计的手段,大多依赖人工操作,效率低下不说,还特别容易出错。

在这个数字化飞速发展的时代,财务数据呈爆发式增长,人工核对账目不仅耗费大量的时间和精力,而且根本无法洞察数据背后那些错综复杂的关系。

真正的数字化审计,应该是利用先进的技术,实现对财务数据的实时监控和深度分析。

就像我在《看透财务造假》这本书里以小说的形式描绘的那样,通过虚构的商业故事,展示了如何运用数据分析、区块链技术等手段,一层层揭开财务造假的伪装,让真相无处遁形。

这本书和马斯克团队的做法不谋而合,都在揭示一个道理:审计的本质不是机械地完成既定流程,而是要怀着对真相的执着追求,去挖掘那些隐藏在暗处的事实。

对于审计和会计从业者来说,《看透财务造假》绝对是一本值得反复研读的好书。

它能帮你打破思维定式,重新认识审计的真正价值。

马斯克美国效率部的这次审计,给全球审计行业敲响了一记沉重的警钟,也为未来的发展指明了方向。

未来的审计,迫切需要更多创新思维和先进技术的融入,必须变革审计委托模式,让审计真正成为公共财产的守护者,发挥出应有的监督作用。

我们期待着更多像马斯克团队这样的创新力量涌现,在审计领域不断探索,让财务造假、资金滥用等问题从此消失在我们的视野中。

Musk's DOGE Audit: A Big Change

Why are some people in America doing such silly and bad things? There's 100 billion dollars going to people who don't have the right papers to get it! Every year, about 50 billion dollars (that's 10 billion dollars every week) might be stolen!

And guess what? There's a video of an old man in America saying: Every year, 2.3 million dollars are spent to count squirrels all over the country; Five million dollars are used just to decide what makes a sandwich legal; One point eight million dollars are spent to tell people to watch out for bumps on the sidewalk; Four million dollars are used to prove that ducks' quacks don't echo. Wow, that makes me think of a funny guy named Xiao Yueyue.

Remember the Enron scandal? It made lots of people lose all their money and hurt the market a lot. Now, there are even bigger problems hiding in the U.S. government's money system. Is it because the people in charge aren't doing their job, or is it because there are more complicated problems? Musk's DOGE team is like superheroes. They stopped 199 wasteful contracts and saved 250 million dollars. In total, they saved the government 36.7 billion dollars.

It's hard to believe that six young guys who don't know anything about accounting or auditing found problems that traditional audits missed for decades. They didn't follow the old, boring "professional procedures" that traditional audits use. While traditional audits were checking papers and numbers the same old way, these guys found a new way. Traditional audits are like old machines that follow the same steps. They seem careful, but they can't find tricky traps and hidden fraud. Our audits are like that too. Auditors check papers and contracts, but they don't realize that companies and suppliers are working together to steal money. Traditional audits don't see it. But Musk's team? They used new ideas and cool technology to break the rules. They used big data to find strange money movements in a huge pile of numbers. It's like finding a needle in a haystack! They also used smart computer programs to guess what the numbers should look like. If something was wrong, they investigated right away. These brave tries and new ideas made problems that traditional audits missed for years finally come to light. So why did traditional audits miss such big money problems?

Maybe we should look at this fairly. It's not that old audits were dumb. It's that they had "reasons" to say things were okay. Even if the reasons weren't good, they were accepted by the people being checked. So audits couldn't say it was wrong, because the rules were made by the people being checked. So audits shouldn't get all the blame. But it's true that the way audits are done and the tools they use are not good enough. When the people being checked are the ones who ask for the audit, it's like working on someone else's turf. They can control everything. The people being checked can make fake papers that look okay. If the auditor says it's wrong, they might lose their job or get in trouble. In some local government audits, the auditor finds bad things between local businesses and the government, but they keep quiet because they don't want to get in trouble. And the tools audits use are mostly old-fashioned and slow. They make lots of mistakes. In this fast-changing digital world, there's so much data that it's impossible to check everything by hand. We need to use cool technology to watch the data in real-time and understand it deeply. That's what I showed in my book "Seeing Through Financial Fraud." I used made-up business stories to show how to use data analysis and blockchain to find hidden fraud. The book and Musk's team both say the same thing: Audits should be about finding the truth, not just following steps.

For people who do audits and accounting, "Seeing Through Financial Fraud" is a great book to read over and over. It helps you think differently and see the real value of audits.

Musk's audit in the U.S. Efficiency Department is like a loud alarm for the whole audit world. It shows us the way to the future. Future audits need new ideas and cool technology. We need to change how audits are done so they can really protect public money and do their job right. We hope more teams like Musk's will come and keep exploring in the audit world. Let's make fraud and bad money use disappear forever.