文章 · 存档
所有价格的尽头只剩下三种“人”和一场AI时代的较量
看懂价格背后的这套拆解逻辑不会立刻让你的房贷少掉一分钱,但它至少能让你在面对这个越来越自动化的世界时多一点清醒:你不是在跟某个单独的商品讨价还价,而是在与一个完整的文明分配体系过招。
很多人第一次认真思考价格这件事都是从吐槽开始的:房价怎么这么贵,咖啡为什么又悄悄涨了,孩子的一节课怎么比自己小时候一年的学费都高。
抱怨过后你也会有一个默认的共识:东西之所以卖这么贵,大概就是因为“原材料+机器设备+人工+一点利润”叠出来的。听上去也合情合理。所有人都会认可价格的组成就是由原材料机器设备人工这样的方式来组成。
你买一件衣服会想到布料、缝纫机、工人;你点一杯奶茶会想到茶叶、牛奶、杯子、店员。但如果就停在这里,其实还是在看表面分工,没看到价格真正的内核。
再问一个问题,原材料又可以拆解成什么呢?
你今天买的棉纱是别人的原材料;可对那家棉纱厂来说,棉花才是原材料。那棉花从哪来?农场。农场的原材料是什么?土地、种子、化肥、农机、柴油、灌溉用水。于是原材料又可以拆解成它的原材料、它的机器设备、它的人工、它的一些其他的一些价格组成。
好,顺着这个逻辑继续往下走,那机器设备成本又是怎么来的呢?
机器设备也是别人制造的一项产品。又回到了机器设备的定价又变成了它的原料、它的能耗、它的人工费等等。你会发现,我们好像掉进了一个循环:你以为在追问这东西为什么这么贵,结果绕了一大圈又回到了那台车床本身也是一件商品。
还有能耗,这部分也可以按照这个逻辑往下拆解。
电价里有电站、水库、煤矿、光伏板;油价里有油田、炼化厂、管道和油轮。拆着拆着会发现我们绕不开一个东西:那水本来就是大自然的东西,本来水在自然界循环,本身是没有人类的价格的,因为没有哪个水是真的大自然出来给你收费的,没有。
真正开始产生价格的那一刻,是当某一个公司去来把水资源开采出来,同样也需要去来花费机器设备、人工等等的。水、矿、土地、阳光、风,这些在自然界里从来不带价签、也不挂吊牌。一旦被人类系统圈进来马上就要经过一轮加工:修水库、架管道、造电站、铺光伏板、建港口,一层一层叠上去,才变成你账单上的水费电费燃料费。
诸如此类的进一步往下拆解,拆解到最后所有的价格组成全部都是由自然物+人工成本+企业利润+国家税收这几个来组成的。你去翻任何一张成本表,不论是原材料、机器折旧、能耗、房租,最后都逃不过这四类:
最底层的自然物,被拿来用;
把它变成商品的人工成本;
中间每一层组织起来、承担风险、设计产品的企业利润;
以及一路上不可避免被征收的国家税收与各类规费。
自然物本身是没有哪个大自然去来向人类收费的,所以自然物的所有的价格的属性都回到了最后这三项:人工成本、企业利润和国家税收。换句话说,大自然不跟你开票,也不催你打款,它只被占有和管理,不收你钱的人,是那个没有话语权的一方。于是,整个世界就清晰了:这个世界上所有的商品价格组成都是:自然物、人工费、企业利润、政权税收。而自然物的成本其实又是可以分解为人工费、企业利润、政权税收的。最终所有商品的价格归根到底只养活了三个“人”:自然人、法人、公法人(政权)。
你每天刷卡、转账、扫码付出去的每一笔钱,看上去是在买一件商品,实质上是在给三种“人”打工:给自然人发工资,让他能继续活下去;给法人留利润,让企业能继续扩张;给公法人提供税收,让这套社会秩序能继续运转。原材料也好,机器也好,能耗也好,只是这三种“人”之间分账的中间环节。
所以价格从来不只是一个数字,而是一张分配权力与资源的结算单。
你感觉贵的东西多半是某一方的分账比例高得离谱,而你没有谈判权而已。
说到这里,问题就变得更尖锐了:未来当AI完整的替代了人类商品制造的全过程以后,人类的商品价格会有重大的变化吗?这个重大变化是商品价格会变得越来越便宜?还是会变得越来越差异化?如果会变得越来越便宜,会不会有一天商品就不需要价格了?因为在整个过程当中没有人是需要在里面劳动的,因为有AI。既然人工成本被AI压到极低,甚至接近于零,那价格是不是也有一天会被挤到接近于零?
听上去很梦幻:生产线全自动,机器人搬运,算法排产,仓储配送都由无人系统完成,人类只需要点菜,不需要劳动,东西就源源不断地出来。
可你再往下拆一次,就会发现AI也逃不出那张结算单。
AI自己的成本,把研发费用什么都刨去以后、模型训练完毕、服务器折旧摊完、算法迭代进入边际成本极低的阶段之后,剩下的部分仍然是:这家掌握AI的企业要拿多少利润,这个国家要在其中收多少税。
而企业的利润有可能会反补回来去养活一片区域的人,或者是登记在他名下的类员工。你可以想象一种极端场景:一个超级AI企业,用少量维护人员和一整套自动化系统,支撑起全球规模的商品生产,它通过股息、分红、福利、社区项目,把部分利润投回到特定区域的人身上,让他们不工作也能活。
政权拿到了税以后会把这个钱给到他的国民,也就是说用这样的方式把国民再养起来。这就像一种放大的基本收入逻辑:既然大部分商品的生产不再需要那么多人的劳动,那么为了维持社会的稳定,政权会用税收和制度把部分成果返还给不再被需要的那部分劳动者。
而企业的利润最终成为不断增长的源泉,用赚到的钱去来购买更多的原材料,购买更多的设备,购买更多的厂房去做大生产。你会看到一幅很魔幻的画面:人类劳动在生产环节的比例越来越低,但资本在设备、算力、土地、资源上的投入越来越高,利润不断回流,税收不停累积。
这个循环到最后会变成什么样子的?从价格结构的角度看,可能出现几种趋势。
一种趋势,是日常商品越来越便宜,稀缺资源越来越贵。所有可以被AI大规模复制的东西:标准化的衣服、家具、数字内容、基础服务等,边际成本会被打到很低,价格逼近企业利润+税收的底线,甚至部分被包装成免费、订阅、会员权益。但是土地、优质城市空间、稀有自然资源、顶级医疗、教育名额、社交圈层这些无法被复制的东西,反而会涨到一个普通人越来越够不着的位置。
另一种趋势,是价格形式被藏起来。你看上去像是在按需取用:平台告诉你零元购、送会员、送流量、送算力,你只要同意协议、留在这里、成为我们生态的一部分。但实际上价格只是从单个商品的标签上转移到了更大的层面:你的时间、你的注意力、你的数据、你的投票、你对某种制度的默许,统统成了新的价格。
再往深处一点,哪怕在一个极端理想的AI社会里几乎所有生产都自动化,每个人都能领到基本生活配给,价格也不会彻底消失,它会变形为“谁先用、谁多用、谁享受更好版本”的排序机制。可能不再叫价格,而是叫等级、配额、权限、优先级。但本质仍然是在这三种“人”之间分账:
自然人抢谁能活得体面;
法人抢谁能扩张得更快;
公法人抢谁能维持更稳的秩序和支持度。
所以当我们把价格拆到底会发现一个残酷但清醒的结论:AI可以大幅改写商品的成本结构,却无法抹掉价格背后的那三种“人”。
它可以让你手里的商品变便宜,让你在很多场景里感觉好像不要钱,但它同时也会把分配的权力集中到更少数、掌握AI和制度设计权的人手里。
真正值得我们焦虑又值得我们期待的,不是“有没有一天商品没有价格”,而是在AI不断压缩人工成本、放大利润和税收的时代,我们这些普通的自然人,是继续在支付那张结算单的人,还是有机会参与到那三个“人”之间的规则设计里。
All prices feed just three "people"
At the End of All Prices, Only Three “People” Are Left and a Big Fight in the AI Time
Understanding the idea behind price, and how to take it apart, will not make your house loan cheaper right now. But it can help you stay clear-headed in a world that is becoming more and more automatic: you are not only talking about the price of one thing, you are facing a whole system that decides how a civilization shares things.
Many people first think about price when they complain:
Why are houses so expensive?
Why did coffee get more expensive again?
Why is one class for kids more money than a whole year of school when we were small?
After complaining, most people will think the same thing: the reason things are expensive is “materials + machines + workers + some profit.” It sounds right. Everyone thinks price is made from materials, machines, and workers.
When you buy a shirt, you think of cloth, sewing machines, workers; when you buy milk tea, you think of tea leaves, milk, cups, store workers.
But if we stop there, we are only looking at the surface. We did not see the real center of price.
Let us ask one more question: What can the “materials” be taken apart into?
The cotton yarn you buy today is someone else's material. But for the yarn factory, cotton is the real material. Where does cotton come from? A farm.
What are the farm's materials? Land, seeds, plant food, farm machines, gas, water for farming.
So the materials can be taken apart into: its own materials, its own machines, its own workers, and some other cost parts.
Okay, let us follow this thinking more. How do machines get their cost?
Machines are also products that other people make. So the price of machines is again: materials, power they use, workers, and more.
We find we fall into a loop: we think we are asking “why is this thing so expensive,” but after a long circle, we see the machine is also a product with the same type of price parts.
Then power cost can also be taken apart in the same way.
The price of electricity has power plants, dams, coal mines, and solar panels inside it; the price of oil has oil fields, factory plants, pipes, and ships inside it.
If we keep breaking it down, we find something that we cannot avoid: water in nature is free. Water comes from nature's own circle. Nature does not ask humans to pay for water. There is no river that asks you for money by itself.
Price starts the moment a company takes the water and works on it. To get water ready for use, companies need machines and workers.
Water, earth, sun, wind — in nature they never have price tags on them.
But once humans take them into our system, we must do work:
build dams, put pipes, make power plants, put down solar panels, build big ports — layer by layer — then they show up as the water bill, the electric bill, and fuel money.
If we keep breaking everything down this way, we find all prices come from four parts:
natural things + worker cost + company profit + government tax.
You can check any cost sheet. No matter if it is materials, machine use, power, or building rent — it still falls into these four parts:
• Natural things that are taken and used
• Worker cost to turn them into products
• Company profit because companies take risks and plan everything
• Government tax and fees that must be paid
And natural things never ask humans for money.
So the price of natural things always becomes the last three parts: worker cost, company profit, and government tax.
Nature does not give you a bill and does not tell you to pay. Nature is just taken and managed. The one who does not ask for money is the one with no voice.
Now we see the truth clearly:
The price of all products in the world is made of natural things + worker cost + company profit + government tax.
And the cost of natural things can again be broken into worker cost, company profit, and government tax.
So in the end, all prices only feed three “people”:
• Natural person (real humans)
• Company person (businesses)
• Public person (the government / power group)
Every time you swipe your card or scan to pay, it looks like you buy a thing.
But really, you are working for those three:
• Giving real humans a salary so they can live
• Giving companies profit so they can grow
• Giving government tax so the system keeps running
Materials, machines, power — they are all only steps for the three to share the money.
So price is never only a number.
It is a bill that shows how power and things are shared.
When something feels too expensive, it usually means one of the three is taking a too-big share — and you do not get to argue.
Now the question becomes sharper:
When AI fully replaces humans in making products, will prices change a lot?
Will things become cheaper and cheaper?
Or will the differences in price become bigger?
If everything gets very cheap, will one day things not need a price at all?
Because no humans need to work anymore — AI does it.
If worker cost becomes almost zero, will price also get close to zero one day?
It sounds like a dream:
Everything made by machines, robots move things, computers plan the work, and no humans need to labor — stuff comes out like magic.
But if we break it down again, we see AI also cannot escape the price bill.
After taking out the cost of research and building AI, after the computer model is trained, after servers are fully paid off and the cost becomes very tiny, there still are two parts:
• How much profit will the AI company take?
• How much tax will the government take?
And the company may use its profit to support people in one area, or people who are listed as “like workers.”
You can imagine: one super AI company, with few workers and full robots, making things for the whole world.
It gives money back to some people near it through shares, gifts, help, and programs, so they can live even if they do not work.
Government takes the tax and gives money to its people too.
This is like a bigger “basic income”:
If most things no longer need many workers, government uses tax and rules to give money back to people who are no longer needed for work — to keep society safe and calm.
Company profit will keep growing and will be used to buy more natural things, more machines, more land, and build bigger buildings for even bigger production.
You will see something strange: human labor becomes less and less needed, but more machines, more computer power, more land, and more natural things are bought. Profit keeps coming, and tax keeps rising.
What will this loop become in the end?
Looking at price structure, we may see different trends:
One trend: everyday goods become cheaper, but rare things become very expensive.
Things that AI can copy a lot — clothes, chairs, digital products, basic services — will have very low added cost, price close to “profit + tax,” maybe even called “free” or “membership.”
But land, good places to live in cities, rare nature things, top medical care, school spots, social groups — they will become so expensive that normal people cannot reach them.
Another trend: prices are hidden.
It looks like “use as you need”:
The platform says “free buy,” “free member,” “free data,” “free power,” just stay here and say yes to the rules.
But the price moved from the item tag into something bigger:
Your time, your attention, your data, your vote, your quiet agreement to the system — these become the new price.
Even in a perfect AI world where everything is made by machines and everyone gets basic things for life, price will not disappear.
It will change into a new rule:
“Who gets to use first?
Who gets more?
Who gets the best version?”
Maybe not called price anymore — maybe called level, quota, permission, priority.
But still the three “people” are taking the share:
• Real humans fight to live better
• Companies fight to grow faster
• Governments fight to stay strong and keep order
So when we break price all the way down, we find a clear truth:
AI can change the cost of products a lot, but it cannot erase the three “people” behind price.
AI can make things cheap and feel like free, but at the same time it will give more power of sharing to fewer people — those who control AI and make the rules.
What we should worry about — and also hope for — is not “Will things be free one day?”
The real question is:
When AI keeps cutting worker cost and making profit and tax bigger, will we normal humans still be only the ones paying the bill, or can we join in making the rules for how the three “people” share the money?