文章 · 存档
我为什么极度厌恶小字营销
这是我自己前两天购买录音笔的遭遇引发的思考。本来我对于中国顶级品牌的小字营销没什么特别感觉的,有的时候甚至认为那是一些博主故意拿出来蹭流量。
可是这次的遭遇让我彻底崩溃了,原来营销就是欺骗消费者吗?原来营销就是愚弄消费者吗?难道营销就是蒙蔽消费者吗?
首先我为什么要买录音笔,因为我需要对我讲课的内容录制下来。我以前有一个还不错的录音笔,但是录音时长太短,只能录几个小时,我通常都是一整天的课,所以每次我都要中间充电,然后下午再录,我觉得很麻烦,所以想找一个能够录一整天的录音笔。
我上网看了很多,都很不错很酷炫,体积也比我以前的录音笔要小很多,很轻便。所以我就设定了一个条件,有AI功能的、能够录音超过12个小时、能够免费转文字、在电脑端可以免费转文字、有APP可以操作设置的等等。于是,各大平台就给我了一大堆推荐。
结果,我却被狠狠上一课:“小字营销”和“暗箱设计”太令人作呕,甚至有些品牌连小字都懒的写,就赌你下了单以后懒得退。
当然我就不说是啥品牌了。
我就先说我自己第一次购买,经过筛选我买了第一个品牌录音笔,很精致,录音时间很长,大概有三十几个小时。买回来以后发现好像跟我先前的条件对不上。
我问售后怎么调设置?他说只能用线控看小屏幕。大哥,我老花啊,那么精致的小录音笔上面的字要多小啊,我咋看得见啊。
然后我问他有没有APP,他说没有。
我说有没有蓝牙功能,他说没有。
这只能是是我自己蠢,天然认为应该有,我为什么就不问一句呢?
那一刻我特别清晰地感受到一个事实:很多产品设计根本不是为“真实的人”做的,而是为PPT上的“卖点”做的。你在宣传页上写着“长续航”,写着“适合长时间会议、讲课”,却在关键操作上给我塞了一个只有年轻好眼力的人才能看得清的线控小字。功能表上的“长续航”是大字,真正关乎体验的“怎么用”“好不好用”全部缩进了肉眼难辨的角落里。
然后我就问他怎么转文字,他说必须要去他的官网,要下载什么旗舰版,下载以后用手机注册,然后用电脑操作。
我问手机可以转吗?因为手机转还毕竟方便。他说不行,只能用电脑版。
实在无语,我就很友好的退货了。
我还不死心,退货以后我就又选择另外一个时长大概能录12个小时的。长得很漂亮很精致,也有自己的APP也可以免费转文字,我想这个应该就符合我的要求了吧,也有蓝牙功能,一切很不错,我就下单了。
果然速度很快,第二天就收到了,感受不错。第一步我就要连蓝牙,真的是,怎么也连不上。于是又找售后,他说必须要下载APP。好吧。我也只能跟着人家产品走了。
于是我下载了APP,还好,马上就连上了。还不错,能录音,有AI总结功能,有转文字。看起来还不错,这次应该是满意了吧。于是我问售后,我在电脑上也可以转文字吧,回答可以,要用包装盒里的一个199元VIP激活就可以?什么,你宣传的不是说免费转文字的吗?怎么还要收费?这不是欺骗消费者吗?
这是我看到的最经典的回答,我给你复述一下你体会:哪里欺骗您了,我们页面上介绍的APP是免费的啊,我们页面上也没有介绍说这个卡片是一直都免费的呀。
我想起了罗永浩老兄站在中杯、大杯、超大杯面前的扇自己耳光的,我这个只想扇自己耳光。我怎么就不长记性呢?还怎么相信产品介绍呢??
人家产品介绍里的确说了,不用手写,语音变文字。当我看到的时候,我还主动问销售,转文字是免费的吗?回答是:电脑版刮开赠品激活卡就能用。人家回答的也没毛病啊,人家也没说这个激活卡是无限的。还是要抽我自己俩大嘴巴。
我自己蠢,我忍了。
到这一步我都还在努力体谅厂商:好吧,你可能是为了稳定、为了兼容,只能走你那一套。
但接下来发生的事情,就已经不是体验不好那么简单,而是赤裸裸的愚弄。
我突然发现他的录音文件不是MP3的,它是一个很奇怪的opus扩展名,我说我的录音要存在电脑里面保存,这个扩展名的文件没有任何办法能播放啊,只能用你的APP才能打开,那太不可思议了吧。
你猜他给我什么建议,说你去百度上查一下怎么转。
我买的是录音笔,我又不是买了一个什么高科技设备啊,你干嘛还要做成这样的一个很奇怪的格式。
你既然说了我就去查了,当然我很讨厌一些无良的搜索引擎,我就AI去查。AI给我想了真的是不少于10种方法去来转换,我挨个都试了,真的挺复杂的,没有一个成功。最后AI给我的结论,这是厂家肯定用了加密手段的文件,只可以在它自己设备里打开,其他都没戏。
这真是让我开眼界了,无良到了这种程度,构建门槛啊,愚弄消费者无知啊。
每天天天讲数据是资产,数据要可迁移、可复用、可沉淀,我记得好像这个还是有立法的。你做一支号称AI录音笔的产品,却把最核心的录音文件做成只有你自己能打开的加密黑箱。对企业来说这叫系统绑架;对普通用户来说这叫只许租不许真正拥有。你以为你能锁住用户吗?你锁死的是未来越来越多的消费者看清你的自大。这些数据没法进入用户自己的知识库、没法进入企业的统一数据中台,只能困在你那一个小小的APP里发霉。
小字营销,就是在大大大大页面里给你画一个又大又甜的饼,然后在小小小小角落里写上小小小小字再把这块饼一点点收回去,只留下那句理直气壮的:“我也没说不可以啊,是你自己没看清。”
如果我们身边的产品都是用这种方式来愚弄消费者的话,消费者如何去来维护自己的权利呢?或者说消费者如何才能够辨别出来哪一些话背后是有逻辑的,哪一些话是真诚的,难不成让所有消费者都要用律师的视角去分析宣传材料才可以购买产品吗?
这让我真的无语,当然我把聊天记录都截屏了,但我也不想让品牌方找我麻烦,毕竟他们都牛气的很,说给我封号就给我封号,我只不过是一个消费者而已。
我真心希望中国的产品能够好好的尊重消费者,每一个正常普通的宣传都能让老百姓真的放心。而不是大字下面有小字,甚至用文字游戏连小字都省了,用这种语言套语言的逻辑,用中国文字博大精深的方式绕晕消费者。
我不指望一篇文章能改变什么,但至少我想把这份愤怒、失望和不甘讲出来。真心希望能够看到更多的真正尊重用户、把条件写清楚、把规则说明白的产品,再也不想被任何一行小字绑架。否则,再这么一直搞下去,受损失的就不再只是消费者了,而是整个行业的未来。
Why I Strongly Hate “Small-Print Marketing”
This is something I thought about after I bought a voice recorder a few days ago.
Before, I did not feel much about small-print marketing from big Chinese brands. Sometimes I even thought some bloggers talked about it only to get more clicks.
But this time, I was fully shocked.
Is marketing really just lying to customers?
Is marketing really just fooling customers?
Is marketing really just hiding the truth from customers?
Why did I want to buy a voice recorder?
Because I need to record my class when I teach.
I had a good recorder before, but it could only record for a few hours.
I usually teach for a whole day, so I needed to charge it in the middle and record again in the afternoon.
It was annoying.
So I wanted a recorder that can record the whole day.
I searched online and saw many cool and nice ones.
They were smaller and lighter than my old one.
So I made a list of what I wanted:
It needed AI functions, record more than 12 hours, change speech to text for free, change speech to text for free on a computer, and have an app to set things up.
Then the platforms gave me many choices.
But then I learned a very hard lesson.
“Small-print marketing” and “dark tricks” are super disgusting.
Some brands do not even write small print.
They just hope you will not return it after you buy it.
I will not say the brand name.
Let me talk about the first one I bought.
It looked very nice.
The recording time was long, more than thirty hours.
But when I used it, I found it did not match what I wanted.
I asked the service person how to change the settings.
He said I must use the tiny screen and a wired controller.
Hey, my eyes are not good.
The words are so small.
How can I see them?
I asked if there was an app.
He said no.
I asked if it had Bluetooth.
He said no.
This was my own fault.
I should have asked.
Why did I just think it must have those things?
At that moment, I understood a sad truth:
Many products are not made for real people.
They are made only for “selling points” written on PPT slides.
You write “long-time use” in big letters.
You say it is “good for long meetings and teaching.”
But the most important part — “how to use it” — is hidden in tiny words that only young people with great eyes can see.
The big words show the shining part.
The small words hide the painful part.
Then I asked how to change speech to text.
He said I must go to their website, download a “special version,” register on my phone, and then use my computer to do it.
I asked, “Can the phone change text? It is easier.”
He said, “No. Only the computer.”
I felt speechless.
So I returned it politely.
I did not give up.
I bought another one that could record about 12 hours.
It looked pretty.
It had its own app.
It could change speech to text for free.
It had Bluetooth.
I thought this one should be good.
So I bought it.
It came fast.
It looked good.
The first thing I wanted to do was connect Bluetooth.
It did not work.
So I asked customer service.
He said I must download the app.
Okay… I must follow their way.
I downloaded the app.
It worked.
It could record.
It had AI summary.
It could change speech to text.
I thought: “This time, I should be happy.”
So I asked, “I can also change text on the computer, right?”
He said, “Yes, use the VIP card inside the box. It costs 199 yuan to activate.”
What?
You said the speech-to-text is free!
Why do I have to pay?
This is lying to customers!
The answer he gave me was the most classic ever:
“I did not lie. The APP is free.
We did not say the card is always free.”
I remembered a joke about a man hitting his own face in front of three drink sizes.
I wanted to hit myself too.
Why did I believe the product page?
It said you did not need to write by hand, and it would turn voice into text.
I asked the sales person if the text change was free.
He said: “Use the card in the box.”
He did not say the card is free forever.
He did not lie.
I was just too silly.
I told myself: It is my fault.
I can take that.
But the next thing made me think this is not just bad experience.
This is fooling me.
I found the recording files were not MP3.
They were a strange file called “opus.”
I said: I need to save my recordings on my computer.
This file type cannot play anywhere.
Only your app can open it.
That is crazy.
You know what the service person told me?
“Go search online how to change it.”
I bought a voice recorder.
Not some high-tech secret machine!
Why make such a strange format?
Since he said so, I searched.
I do not like some bad search engines, so I asked AI.
AI gave me not less than ten ways to change it.
They were all hard.
None worked.
AI later told me:
“The company must use special lock on the file.
It can only open in their own app.”
Wow.
This is so mean.
They are building walls to trap customers.
They think users are stupid.
Every day they say: “Data is a treasure. Data must be free to move.”
I remember there are laws about this.
You say your product is an AI recorder, but you lock the most important data.
For companies, this is called “system jail.”
For normal people, this means you do not really own your own data.
You think you can lock users inside your APP?
You are locking away your future customers.
These files cannot go to people's own knowledge tools.
They cannot go into a company's data system.
They are stuck forever in your tiny app.
Small-print marketing means you draw a big sweet cake with big words.
Then hide rules with tiny tiny words.
And later you say:
“I did not lie. You just did not read carefully.”
If many products fool customers like this,
how can we protect our rights?
How can we know which words are true?
Do we all have to think like lawyers before buying anything?
I felt so tired.
Of course, I saved all chat screenshots.
But I do not want trouble.
They are strong big brands.
They can block me anytime.
I am just a normal customer.
I really hope Chinese products can respect customers more.
I hope people can buy things without fear.
Not big words and then tiny words.
Not word games.
Not tricks to make people confused.
I know my small article cannot change the world.
But I want to speak out my anger, my sadness, and my “not giving up.”
I hope to see more honest products that write rules clearly.
I never want to be caught by any tiny words again.
If this bad way keeps going, the ones who lose are not only customers.
It will hurt the future of the whole industry.