文章 · 存档
你到底要怎么过完这一生,读完《哲学家的最后一课》有感
读完朱锐教授的《哲学家的最后一课》这本书,我有点舍不得把书合上。不是因为一本书有多伟大,而是因为它把我这些年零零碎碎时常飘在半空里的那些关于死亡、人生意义、内卷、不确定性、爱与连接等等一下子都勾了出来,逼着我坐下来像个真的成年人一样认真想一想:你到底要怎么过完这一生。
先从一个最“俗”的问题说起:“职业”和“志业”。
书里一开始就谈“职业”和“志业”。职业是让你能赚钱、养家、在这个世界上站住脚的一份工作;志业,是你这一生真正想追求的那件事,是你愿意一生不停打磨的那个方向。看上去很像鸡汤,但当一个哲学家在弥留之际仍然拿这个问题出来说,我会觉得,这应该就是一个清单,你到底用多少时间活在你的职业里,又有多少时间真的活在你的志业中。
我自己反思了一下,我真正有产出感的时候,几乎从来不是坐在书桌前对着电脑的那种标准工作姿势。地铁上、飞机上、开车的时候,好像只有这三个地方时我创意最多。
地铁上很吵、很挤、很不舒服,刷短视频信号也不太好,你反而被迫只能和自己待着,脑子开始乱想,然后有些想法就突然冒出来。
飞机上干脆是被强制离线,网络断掉以后要么睡觉、要么看书,要么看完电影、要么就发呆,发呆发着发着就开始思考。
开车眼睛必须盯着前方,手脚在执行固定的动作,大脑却很自由,听着各种乱七八糟的内容,一句话点燃一个念头,念头再点燃另一个念头。
我后来给自己下了一个结论:能让我思考有创意的环境都有这些共同点:不太舒服、离线、或者没法舒服的随便做任何事,包括刷短视频。也许我应该把我所有的环境尽量都变成这一类的环境,强制飞行模式、别太舒服,别那么容易分心,要么就干脆强制离线让大脑没得逃,只能老老实实面对自己的想法。
这本书真正抓住我的,是它用一种非常温和却极其锋利的方式讲死亡。
动物的害怕大多是应激性的,而人类的恐惧往往是前瞻性的。
动物怕的是此刻被攻击,人类怕的是未来会发生什么。我们恐惧的不仅仅是死亡本身,而是各种不确定:我会不会痛?我会不会拖累家人?我还有没有遗愿未了?恐惧本身就是对不确定性的放大。某种意义上不确定性是人类在这个世界上最后的一块遮羞布,我们既靠它证明自己还活着,又拼命想把它消灭。
我一直觉得人应该活在不确定性里面,这才是人的存在方式。但人又偏偏长了一颗爱搞确定性的脑子,要预测,要规划,要做战略,要把可能性一条一条列出来,然后对着这些确定性去发射行动。于是就有了产品规划、公司战略、个人发展路线图……
回到死亡这件事上,当你真的坐下来把你所能想到的关于死亡的各种可能全都想一遍,什么肉体的痛苦、意识的消失、家人的哀伤、遗愿未了,你会发现真正让你恐惧的并不是死本身,而是你觉得自己还没活完。
书里引用苏格拉底的一段话我很喜欢:死亡不过是灵魂从身体中脱离出来,实现灵肉分离的状态。身体要吃、要睡、要享乐、会恐惧,会引发争夺,会阻碍我们追求真理。哲学家的工作就是尽量让灵魂从身体的羁绊中解脱出来。换句话说,如果一个人已经把全部精力都投入到真正的学习和真正的创新中,他的灵魂在很大程度上已经从肉体的各种小欲望里抽身出来了,那他在世之时就已经在过一种天堂式的生活。
所以,我给自己写了一条小注解:天堂不是死后才去的地方,而是当你全心全意地在学习、在创造,在用你认为最有价值的方式使用你的时间时,你其实就已经站在天堂门口了,只看你自己认不认。
我脑子里有一个比喻。
有的电脑主机外壳豪华、灯光炫酷、水冷系统顶配、显卡堆到天上,结果整天用来打那种纯粹消磨时间的游戏;
有的破旧电脑,外壳都没有,芯片也早就落后了,却在上面写出了旷世奇作。
同样,有的人富有,有的人贫穷,本质上都不影响思考的可能性。真正决定一台机器价值的,从来不是配置,而是它被用来做什么。
书里有一个死亡比喻我特别喜欢。
细胞必须不断死亡,生命才能持续。那些不肯死的细胞就是癌细胞。它们以为自己一直活着就是胜利,结果是把整个生命体拖进毁灭。人类历史也是这样,如果从古至今所有生过的人都不死,照人口学的估算,大概一千多亿人现在全挤在地球上,这个星球早就撑爆了。某种意义上,死亡是生命延续的前提,而不是生命的敌人。
这本书还讲到一个词“僭越”。苏格拉底说,我们很多恐惧其实是一种知识意义上的僭越。你根本不了解的东西,却提前给自己配了一份“害怕”,实际上你还不配“害怕”。这一点在死亡问题上尤其明显:多数人从来没认真思考过“死是什么”“我到底在怕什么”,就提前宣告“我很害怕死亡”。你连你怕的东西是什么都说不清,那你到底在怕什么?
关于永生,我自己在读的时候,脑子里冒出了一个有点好玩的画面:在电脑彻底关机永不再开之前,最好先把硬盘里所有信息备份到一个“永生云盘”里。这个备份不是在关机前一瞬间才开始,而是当你知道并同意和永生系统对接的那一刻起,它就悄悄开始了。等到主机彻底关机以后,所有信息都沉睡在云端,直到有一天一个真正的机主重新把这些带着原标签的信息加载回某个系统,这个你就以另一种形态重启了。而那些从未接入过永生云盘的信息,就永远消失在黑暗中。
人这一生其实是在决定要不要把自己备份到某种更长远的系统里。这个系统可以是知识,可以是作品,可以是你影响过的人,可以是你留下的爱和连接。到那一刻,肉体只是设备,真正会被保留下来的,是你曾经输出过什么。
书里有一段讲赫尔曼·黑塞的故事:一个有天赋的男孩,十七岁就因为肺炎去世了,去世前两天他做了一个美丽的梦,在梦中他见到了爸爸妈妈,他也寻得自己理想的事业并与一个女孩相爱。所有人都替他惋惜,觉得他还没来得及凭天赋和努力功成名就。然而黑塞却说,这个男孩的一生是值得庆祝的,因为在他能力所及的范围内,他已经把能做的事情都做了,没有留下什么遗憾。
让我想起一个美剧片段:一个即将失明的男孩,在眼睛完全看不见之前只想完成三件小小的心愿——面对面看一眼喜欢的女孩、疯狂地飙一次车、在法律允许的范围内真正见识一下女人是什么样子。在医生和护士曲线救国的帮助下,他居然真的一个个实现了。你说,他的人生是不是有缺憾?客观上当然有。但在他自己那一刻的感受里,他的人生是圆满的。
死亡的恐惧到最后都要回到一个问题上:你有没有在你能力所及的范围内,把你最想做的那件事做好?如果答案是“是”,死亡就变成了一种可接受的不确定;如果答案是“否”,哪怕你再怎么信仰哲学、信仰宗教,你仍然会纠结。
书里还谈到大学。我也很赞同作者那句话:上大学不是目的,毕业也不是目的,目的是读书,目的是开阔自己的思维,让自己成为“大写的人”。大学在历史上其实是一个很年轻的制度,是特定时代的产物,不是一个永恒不变的标准配置。但在中国的现实里,不上大学几乎必然被歧视——你想要不被歧视,必须做出一个远远超出平均值的成就。这是一种社会结构性的内卷:学历成了最低门槛,你先要跨过去,才有资格谈其他。
这也逼着我去问自己:那你呢?王峰,你的人生意义到底是什么?老实说,我现在也没想明白一个终极答案。如果硬要给当下的自己写一句话,可能是这样:此刻,我的人生意义,是尽我所能让家庭活得稳定、让自己有能力支撑这个稳定,同时用我能理解的财务、商业和AI的方式去创造一些东西,让这个世界因为我的存在,哪怕只是一点点,变得更有序、更清醒一点。至于这是不是终极意义,我不敢说,但至少此刻,我是朝着这个方向在走。
这本书对“爱”也有一个角度,我很认同。爱是什么?爱是人与人之间最好的连接方式。
圣经里说“爱是永不止息”,我自己的理解是:上帝之所以在圣经里不断强调“爱”,就是在强调连接,希望人和人连接,人和上帝连接。人和人之间的关系不是互相利用、互相算计、互相欺骗,而是愿意承担、愿意说真话、愿意一起面对后果。这种连接本质上也是一种永生备份:你在别人心里留下什么,你就以什么样的形态继续存在着。
说到这里,再绕回一个很现实的问题:职业没有高低贵贱,但薪水的确有高低多寡,这到底由什么决定?我现在更倾向于一个答案:影响力,或者说掌控力。谁能掌控更多资源,让这些资源在他手上增值,谁就会拥有更多财富;谁能影响更多人,让更多人愿意为他的时间、作品、决策买单,谁就会更有钱。聪明不等于掌控力,掌控力也不等于道德高尚,但在财富这件事情上,它的确是一个决定性的变量。
这就牵涉到一个很现实的场域选择问题。一个伟大的小提琴家在金色大厅演出一场可以赚很多钱;同一个人如果跑到地铁站演奏,可能连几块钱的小费都收不到。不是因为他演奏得不好,而是因为听众不在那儿。所谓流量,很多时候就是你站错了地方。真正重要的是,你能不能找到那个为你而来的场域,而不是站在所有人匆匆路过的地方证明自己。
对我个人来说这也是一个拉扯,如果我去大公司当CFO,站在一个巨大的场域中,我的社会名片会好看得多,掌控的资产也会多得多,影响力自然放大。但代价是,我必须牺牲大量属于自己的时间、喜好和平静。那不是一份简单的职业选择,而是一份人生场域的选择。而如果我像现在这样,安安静静地写、讲、思考、创造,最大的痛苦就是:你做了很多东西,却没有那么多人看到。就像拼命想要在视频号上赚取流量的时候,就如同小提琴家站在地铁站演奏,没人在乎你,因为你站错的地方。这一刻,我没有标准答案,只能承认这是我必须自己承担的不确定性。
书名叫《哲学家的最后一课》,对我来说它更像是一个成年人给自己的中场提醒,死亡是必修课,但在那之前,你总得先把怎么活这门课写一写作业。死亡会来,恐惧也不会完全消失,不确定性永远在那里晃。如果在有限时间里你愿意认真地去思考、去学习、去创造、去连接、去影响哪怕少数几个人,那么当你有一天真的走到生命的边缘时,至少可以比较坦然地说一句:在我能力所及的范围内,我没有白来这一趟。
How do you really want to live your whole life?
How do you really want to live your whole life? My thoughts after reading The Philosopher's Last Lesson
After I finished Professor Zhu Rui's book The Philosopher's Last Lesson, I did not want to close it right away.
Not because the book is somehow “great,” but because it pulled out so many things that have been floating in my mind for years—death, the meaning of life, endless competition, uncertainty, love, and connection.
It forced me to sit down like a real adult and think seriously: how do you really want to live out this whole life?
First, let me start with the most “ordinary” question: “job” and “life calling.”
At the beginning, the book talks about “job” and “life calling.”
A job is the work that lets you make money, support your family, and stand firmly in this world.
A life calling is the thing you truly want to chase in this life, the direction you are willing to polish and improve for your whole life.
It sounds a bit like feel-good talk, but when a philosopher is still talking about this question near the end of life, I feel it is like a checklist: how much time do you live inside your job, and how much time do you truly live inside your calling?
I reflected on myself for a moment.
When I truly feel productive, it is almost never when I sit at a desk in the “standard work pose” facing a computer.
On the subway, on an airplane, and while driving—these seem to be the three places where I have the most ideas.
The subway is noisy, crowded, and uncomfortable, and the signal is not great for short videos, so you are forced to stay with yourself.
Your mind starts to wander, and then some ideas suddenly pop up.
On an airplane, you are basically forced to be offline.
When the internet is cut, you either sleep, read, watch a movie, or just stare into space.
And while you are staring, you start to think.
When driving, your eyes must watch the road, and your hands and feet do fixed actions, but your brain feels free.
You listen to all kinds of random things, and one sentence lights one thought, and that thought lights another thought.
Later I gave myself a conclusion: the environments that help me think and create all share the same points.
They are not very comfortable, or they are offline, or they do not let you comfortably do anything you want, including scrolling short videos.
Maybe I should try to turn more of my environments into this kind of environment: forced airplane mode, not too comfortable, not so easy to get distracted, or just forced offline so my brain has nowhere to run and must honestly face its own thoughts.
What truly grabbed me about this book is how it talks about death in a very gentle but extremely sharp way.
Animals mostly fear in a reactive way, but human fear is often forward-looking.
Animals fear being attacked right now.
Humans fear what might happen in the future.
We fear not only death itself, but all kinds of uncertainty: Will I feel pain? Will I burden my family? Do I have unfinished wishes?
Fear itself is an amplifier of uncertainty.
In a way, uncertainty is the last “cover” humans have in this world.
We use it to prove we are still alive, and at the same time we try desperately to erase it.
I have always felt that people should live inside uncertainty.
That is the human way of being.
But humans also have a brain that loves certainty.
We want to predict, plan, make strategy, list every possible path, and then shoot actions at those “certainties.”
So we have product plans, company strategy, personal growth roadmaps…
When it comes back to death, if you truly sit down and think through every possible thing about death you can imagine—physical pain, the end of awareness, your family's sadness, unfinished wishes—you will find that what you fear is not death itself, but the feeling that you have not finished living.
The book quotes a line from Socrates that I really like.
He says death is just the soul leaving the body, a state where soul and body separate.
The body wants to eat, sleep, and enjoy pleasure.
It feels fear, it creates conflict, and it blocks our search for truth.
A philosopher's work is to free the soul from the body's chains as much as possible.
In other words, if a person has put all their energy into real learning and real creation, then their soul has already stepped away from many small desires of the body.
Then while they are alive, they are already living a kind of “heaven-like” life.
So I wrote a small note for myself: heaven is not a place you go only after you die.
It is when you give yourself fully to learning and creating, and when you use your time in the way you believe is most valuable.
In that moment, you are already standing at the gate of heaven—it only depends on whether you admit it.
I have a metaphor in my mind.
Some computers have a fancy case, cool lights, top-level water cooling, and a huge graphics card, but they are used all day for games that only kill time.
Some old broken computers do not even have a case, and their chips are outdated, yet someone writes a world-changing masterpiece on them.
In the same way, some people are rich and some are poor, but that does not truly block the possibility of thinking.
What decides the value of a machine is never its specs, but what it is used to do.
There is a death metaphor in the book that I especially like.
Cells must keep dying so life can continue.
Cells that refuse to die are cancer cells.
They think staying alive forever is victory, but in the end they drag the whole body into destruction.
Human history is the same.
If every person who has ever lived from ancient times until now never died, then based on population estimates, about one hundred billion people would be crowded on Earth right now, and this planet would have exploded already.
In a way, death is a condition for life to continue, not an enemy of life.
The book also talks about a word: “overstepping.”
Socrates says many fears are actually “overstepping” in the sense of knowledge.
You do not understand something at all, yet you give yourself a full package of “fear” in advance.
In a way, you are not even qualified to “fear” it yet.
This is especially clear with death.
Most people never truly think about “What is death?” and “What am I really afraid of?”
They just announce early, “I am afraid of death.”
If you cannot even say clearly what you are afraid of, then what are you really afraid of?
About immortality, while I was reading, a funny picture appeared in my mind.
Before a computer shuts down forever and never turns on again, it would be best to back up everything on the hard drive to an “immortal cloud drive.”
This backup does not start only in the last second before shutdown.
It starts quietly the moment you know about the system and agree to connect to it.
After the machine fully shuts down, all the information sleeps in the cloud.
Then one day, when a real owner loads that labeled information into a system again, “you” restart in another form.
And the information that never connected to the immortal cloud drive disappears into darkness forever.
A human life is actually about deciding whether you want to back yourself up into some longer-lasting system.
That system can be knowledge, your work, the people you influenced, or the love and connection you left behind.
At that point, the body is just hardware.
What will truly stay is what you once gave to the world.
The book tells a story about Hermann Hesse.
A talented boy died of pneumonia at seventeen.
Two days before he died, he had a beautiful dream.
In the dream, he saw his parents, found his ideal life work, and fell in love with a girl.
Everyone felt sorry for him, thinking he had no time to become famous through talent and hard work.
But Hesse said this boy's life was worth celebrating, because within what he was able to do, he had already done what he could, and left no real regret.
This reminded me of a scene from an American TV show: a boy who was about to go blind wanted to finish three small wishes before he could not see at all—see the girl he liked face to face, drive crazily fast one time, and within what the law allowed, truly see what women are like.
With creative help from doctors and nurses, he actually did them one by one.
So, was his life missing something?
Objectively, yes.
But in how he felt at that moment, his life was complete.
In the end, fear of death always returns to one question:
Within what you are able to do, did you do the one thing you most wanted to do well?
If the answer is “yes,” death becomes an uncertainty you can accept.
If the answer is “no,” then even if you believe in philosophy or believe in religion, you will still feel stuck.
The book also talks about college.
I strongly agree with the author's line: going to college is not the goal, and graduating is not the goal.
The goal is reading, widening your mind, and becoming a “real person” in the fullest sense.
In history, the university system is actually very young.
It is a product of a certain time, not an eternal standard setup.
But in China's reality, if you do not go to college, you will almost surely be looked down on.
If you want to avoid that, you must achieve something far above average.
This is a structural kind of endless competition: education becomes the lowest entry ticket.
You must cross it first before you are even allowed to talk about anything else.
This also pushed me to ask myself: what about you?
Wang Feng, what is the meaning of your life?
To be honest, I still have not found a final answer.
If I must write one sentence for myself right now, it might be this:
At this moment, my life meaning is to do my best to keep my family stable, and make sure I have the ability to support that stability, and at the same time use the ways I understand—finance, business, and AI—to create some things, so that because I exist, even if only a little, this world becomes more ordered and a bit more clear.
As for whether this is the ultimate meaning, I cannot say, but at least right now, I am walking in this direction.
The book also has an angle on “love,” and I agree with it.
What is love?
Love is the best way for people to connect with each other.
The Bible says, “Love never ends.”
My understanding is: God keeps stressing “love” in the Bible because God is stressing connection—hoping people connect with people, and people connect with God.
Relationships between people are not about using each other, calculating against each other, or tricking each other.
They are about being willing to carry responsibility, willing to tell the truth, and willing to face results together.
This kind of connection is also a kind of immortal backup.
What you leave in other people's hearts is the form in which you continue to exist.
Now, coming back to a very real question:
Jobs are not noble or low, but pay truly can be high or low.
What decides that?
I now lean toward one answer: influence, or control.
Who can control more resources, and make those resources grow in value in their hands, will have more wealth.
Who can influence more people, so more people are willing to pay for their time, work, and decisions, will be richer.
Being smart is not the same as having control.
Having control is also not the same as being morally good.
But in the matter of money, it truly is a deciding variable.
This leads to a very real question of choosing the right “place.”
A great violinist can earn a lot of money by playing one concert in a golden hall.
The same person, playing in a subway station, may not even get a few dollars in tips.
It is not because he plays badly.
It is because the audience is not there.
What people call “traffic” often just means you are standing in the wrong place.
What truly matters is whether you can find the place where people come for you, not proving yourself where everyone rushes past.
For me personally, this is also a struggle.
If I go to a big company as a CFO and stand in a huge arena, my social “business card” will look much better, I will control far more assets, and my influence will naturally grow.
But the cost is that I must give up a lot of my own time, preferences, and calm.
This is not just a simple career choice.
It is a life arena choice.
If I stay like now—quietly writing, teaching, thinking, creating—the biggest pain is this: you make many things, but not many people see them.
When you fight hard for traffic on video platforms, it is like the violinist playing in the subway station.
No one cares, because you are standing in the wrong place.
At this moment, I have no standard answer.
I can only admit this is an uncertainty I must carry myself.
The book is called The Philosopher's Last Lesson.
For me, it feels more like a mid-life reminder to myself as an adult.
Death is a required class, but before that, you still have to do the homework for the class called “how to live.”
Death will come, fear will not fully disappear, and uncertainty will always sway there.
If, in limited time, you are willing to seriously think, learn, create, connect, and influence even a small number of people, then when you one day truly reach the edge of life, you can at least say calmly:
Within what I was able to do, I did not come here for nothing.