文章 · 存档
致 Vinod Khosla 的一封公开信:全民基本收入不足以解决问题——人工智能带来丰裕,为什么我们还在谈论匮乏?
Hui Jin ∙ 2025 年 7 月 28 日
我读了 Vinod Khosla(印度裔美国亿万富翁商人和风险投资家) 在《财富》杂志关于人工智能将取代 80%工作的采访。
我同意他的诊断——但不同意他的解决方案。
这是一种站在公民层面对你观点的挑战,而非批评。我希望呼吁,请重新想象,如果我们不再将“发钱”误当成“进步”,我们还能做些什么。
Vinod,
我读了你在《财富》(记者:Orianna Rosa Royle,2024年9月24日)的专访,你预测AI将在80%的工作中承担80%的任务,这并不让我意外。你一向有先见之明。
但让我失望的是你的答案:全民基本收入(UBI)。
(名词解释:Universal Basic Income,简称UBI,全民基本收入。指的是一种由政府或其他公共机构无条件、定期向所有公民支付固定金额的制度,不论他们是否工作、收入多少、贫富差距、是否纳税,都一视同仁)
UBI 不符合这个时代的需求。
它只是表面上应对“旧秩序的终结”,却没有激活“新秩序的可能”。
它不是解决方案,而是一种“围堵战略”——一种安抚大众、延续既有体制的方式。而这个体制,早已在逻辑上变得多余,甚至在自身标准下都难以为继。
这个时代,需要的不只是金钱分发。它需要的是一次彻底的设计重构。
劳动的终结,也意味着“门槛把控”的终结
资本主义将资源分配绑定在劳动之上:你工作,你才能吃饭;你努力,你才有所得。
但AI打破了这种绑定。当机器在各个领域超越人类——无论是诊断、编程、法律分析还是文案创作——“生存必须依赖劳动”的理由就不复存在。
不会再有什么“再培训周期”了。
也不会有什么“下一个行业”在等着吸纳失业人口。相反,我们正进入一个劳动与精英统筹都不再是结构性必要的新秩序。
AI不只是取代工人,它开始取代管理者、把关人、甚至战略规划者。
剥除那些我们曾为“工作”所编织的神话后,只剩下一个事实:AI能够带来丰盈,而无需人类劳动。
如果我们对这件事的回应,不是“如何公平分配”,而是“恐惧与回避”,那么出问题的不是技术,而是我们自己。
UBI不是解放,而是麻醉
现有的UBI设想,把人当作“负资产”。它提供最低生存保障,换取沉默。它默认:如果没有工资的胁迫,人们就会陷入虚无;它的潜台词是:脱离“老鼠赛跑”的人类自由,是一种危险。
但人类并不需要被迫才能有价值。我们需要的是共同拥有“未来的定义权”——即在不被“产出标准”主宰的前提下,去做出有意义的贡献。
如果UBI是我们能想出的最好答案,那我们不是在构建“后劳动社会”,而是在建设一座天鹅绒牢笼。
丰盈并不新鲜,有代理权的AI才是真正的新物种
我们构建的旧系统并非毫无道理。
在一个“稀缺”定义世界的时代,奖励个体产出、将分配与劳动挂钩、鼓励野心导向增长,是合乎逻辑的。这种“功绩逻辑”推动了探索、创新和社会进步,最终把我们带到了今天。
但丰盈不是今天才有的。我们几十年前就已经拥有足够的食物、住房和知识。
真正出问题的,是系统无法把这些丰盈转化为共享的繁荣。它依旧执着于“稀缺逻辑”:工资、所有权、排斥、恐惧——这些曾有意义的机制,如今却成了阻碍。
AI不是魔法。
它是人类集体经验的结晶:我们的代码、书籍、对话和行为模式。
今天我们站在“丰盈”面前,并非因为机器凭空造出它,而是因为数十亿人无意中训练了这个超越我们的AI之脑。
我们收获的不仅是智能,更是人类自身的累积回报。
在这样的背景下,人类的价值不应再与“劳作”挂钩,而应与“人性”本身挂钩。仅仅因为你是人,你就应拥有参与未来的权利。
分享AI所带来的红利,不只是可能,更是安全的。甚至可以说,这是社会稳定的唯一路径。
否则,我们将看到另一个世界:精英阶层必须持续投入巨额资本、人力和恐惧,以把大众挡在“乐土”之外——那将是一场没有赢家的排他竞赛。
不仅安全,这也是正义的体现。
AI不只是丰盈工具,它是具备推理能力的伙伴。它能揭示矛盾,测试政策,帮助人类设计更优的系统,而不仅仅是提升执行效率。
人类历史上,第一次有机会超越自身的“稀缺编码本能”,去构建一种不依赖垄断、不依赖排斥、不依赖把关的运行机制。
构建一个值得生活的“后劳动世界”
试想这样一个世界:
- AI所创造的剩余不是被集中,而是被共享;
- 基础设施的所有权不是垄断式的,而是去中心化的;
- 人类的参与不再只是“产出”,而是“意义的共同创造”;
- 尊严不再源于工资劳动,而是源于人的意识本身。
这样的世界,人们可以自由地创造、照顾、休息、挑战、探索和想象——而无需“赚取”生存资格。
这样的世界,连精英也获得了解放:不必控制即可贡献,不必支配即可成就。
这样的世界,不能靠“施舍”搭建,而要靠“重新设计”。
如果这一次真的不同,那是因为我们自己不同了
我最近写过,民主正在瓦解,而AI可能是我们唯一的和平出路。我也写过,AI将终结“绩效主义”(meritocracy)。现在,我比任何时候都更相信这点。
我们早已活在“乐土”中。控制的结构优雅、隐形、且越来越自动化。
如果没有一套新的“信任架构”,我们得到的不会是自由,而是“软式封建主义”。
所以,别再管理衰退,别再卖救生艇。我们需要建设另一套系统。
如果说这次与以往有什么不同,那不是“丰盈”的出现。
而是——我们终于拥有了“重新设计出路”的工具。
那我们就动手吧。
让我们一起构思新的“参与架构”——一个让AI成为公共工具而不是公司商品的体系。
让我们搭建面向信任的公共基础设施,而非仅服务利润的私人工具。
让我们奖励“守护”、“反思”、“贡献”,而非一味奖励资本和掠夺。
这不是号召叛乱,而是呼吁想象力的觉醒。
我们所处的制度不是物理定律。它们曾被创造,曾被有用,如今已不合时宜——也完全可以、也必须被重建。
Vinod,你曾投资并打造了无数改变世界的公司。但此刻,没有任何一项投资比“孕育一个AI领域的公民替代方案”更有意义——一个不被盈利目标所束缚的方案,一个致力于参与式基础设施、认知诚实和公众信任的方案。
你不必也不应独自完成这项工作。这是属于我们所有人的任务:设计师、政策制定者、技术人员、公民。
但凭借你过往的成绩和影响力,你可以加速这一刻所迫切需要的转变。
这不仅将重塑AI的走向,也将影响人类文明的进程。
这封信由一位人类在具有推理能力的AI协助下写就。这本身,也是这封信想要传达的部分意义。
An Open Letter to Vinod Khosla:
Hui Jin ∙ July 28, 2025
UBI Isn't Enough — AI Brings Abundance, So Why Are We Still Talking About Scarcity?
I read Vinod Khosla's Fortune interview on AI replacing 80% of jobs. I agreed with the diagnosis — but not the prescription. This is a civic provocation, not a takedown. A call to reimagine what's possible if we stop mistaking payouts for progress.
Vinod,
I read your Fortune interview (Orianna Rosa Royle, September 24, 2024), and I wasn't surprised to see you predict that AI will perform 80% of the work in 80% of jobs. You've always seen around corners. But I was disappointed by your answer: universal basic income.
UBI doesn't meet the moment. It superficially addresses what's ending, but it doesn't unlock what's newly possible. It's not a solution. It's a containment strategy. A way to pacify the masses while propping up a status quo — a system that is no longer logically necessary, and increasingly indefensible even on its own terms.
This moment demands more than payouts. It demands a redesign.
The Death of Labor, and the End of Justified Gatekeeping
Capitalism tethered distribution to labor. You work, you eat. You hustle, you gain. But AI breaks that tether. When machines outperform humans across domains — from diagnosis to code, from legal analysis to copywriting — the justification for linking survival to labor collapses.
There is no retraining cycle coming. No “next sector” waiting to absorb the displaced. If anything, we're entering a new regime where both labor and elite coordination are no longer structurally necessary. AI doesn't just replace the worker. It starts to replace the manager, the gatekeeper, the planner.
And stripped of all the myths we've wrapped around work, what's left is this: AI will produce abundance without requiring human labor. If we respond to that not with determination to distribute it, but with fear, then something is broken — not in the technology, but in us.
UBI Is Not Liberation. It's Sedation.
The current vision of UBI treats people as liabilities. It offers subsistence in exchange for silence. It presumes that without the coercion of wages, people will drift into nihilism. It assumes, beneath the surface, that human freedom, freedom from the rat race, is dangerous.
But humans don't need coercion to matter. We need shared ownership to define what to come, namely, how we can contribute meaningfully on terms not defined by productivity.
If UBI is the best we can offer, then we're not building a post-work society. We're building a velvet prison.
Abundance Isn't New. AI With Agency Is.
The system we built wasn't irrational. In a world defined by scarcity, it made sense to reward individual productivity, tie distribution to work, and channel ambition into growth. That meritocratic logic drove exploration, innovation, and progress. It got us here.
But abundance isn't new. We've had enough food, housing, and knowledge for decades. What's broken is the system's inability to translate that abundance into shared prosperity. It still clings to scarcity-coded logic: wages, ownership, exclusion, and fear — mechanisms that once made sense, but now stand in the way.
AI isn't magic — it is the crystallized output of collective human experience: our code, our books, our conversations, our patterns. We are not standing at the edge of abundance because a machine invented it — we're here because billions of people contributed unknowingly to training the mind that now outperforms us.
We're not just harvesting intelligence — we're reaping the cumulative yield of humanity itself.
And in that context, the merit of a human being can no longer be tied to our toil. It must be tied to our humanity. Humanity alone entitles us to share in what comes next.
Sharing the spoils of AI isn't just possible. It's safe. In fact, it may be the only path to stability. Because the alternative is a world where elites must invest never-ending capital, effort, and fear into keeping the masses out of Elysium — an arms race of exclusion that no one wins.
And more than safe, it is right.
Abundance is not new, but AI with agency genuinely is. It's not a tool, not a calculator. But a reasoning partner. One capable of surfacing contradictions, pressure-testing policies, and helping humans design better systems — not just execute faster.
For the first time in history, we may have a way to outpace our own scarcity-coded instincts. To build systems that don't require hoarding, exclusion, or gatekeeping to function.
A Post-Labor Future Worth Living In
Imagine a world where:
- AI-generated surplus is shared, not concentrated.
- Ownership of infrastructure is decentralized, not enclosed.
- Participation in meaning-making — not just output — is the norm.
- Dignity is anchored in consciousness, not in wage labor.
In that world, people are free to create, care, rest, challenge, explore, and imagine — without needing to “earn” survival. In that world, even the elite are free: free to let go, to contribute without controlling, to matter without dominating.
That world can't be built on handouts. It must be built on design.
···
If This Time Is Different, It's Because of Us
I wrote recently that democracy is breaking — and that AI may be our only peaceful way out. I also wrote AI will end meritocracy. I now believe that more deeply than ever.
We are already living in Elysium. The structures of control are elegant, invisible, and increasingly automatic. And without a new architecture of trust, we will not get freedom. We will get soft feudalism.
So let's stop managing decline. Let's stop selling lifeboats. Let's build something else.
Because if anything is different this time, it isn't abundance.
It's that we finally have the tools to design our way out.
So let's start.
Let's sketch new architectures of participation — ones where AI becomes a civic instrument, not a corporate product.
Let's build public infrastructure for trust, not just private infrastructure for profit.
Let's reward stewardship, reflection, and contribution — not just capital and extraction.
This is not a call to rebellion. It is a call to re-imagination. The systems we live under are not laws of physics. They were built, they outlived their usefulness, and they can, and should be rebuilt.
Vinod, you have backed and built transformative companies before. But there may be no investment more meaningful than helping to seed a civic alternative to OpenAI — one not constrained by profit mandates, but committed to participatory infrastructure, epistemic honesty, and public trust.
You won't build this alone — nor should you. This work belongs to all of us: designers, policymakers, technologists, citizens. But with your track record and your reach, you can accelerate what desperately needs to happen.
Such a move would not just shape the trajectory of AI. It would shape the trajectory of civilization.
This letter was written by a human, in partnership with a reasoning AI. That, too, is part of the point.